‘Sharp Stick’ Review: Lena Dunham’s Third Major Act Is Her First Disappointment
23.01.2022 - 07:25
/ variety.com
Owen Gleiberman Chief Film CriticFor a decade, Lena Dunham has kept more than busy, executive producing TV series like “Camping” and “Generation” and putting out her memoir. Yet she’s been notably selective about her main slate of projects, and “Sharp Stick,” which premiered tonight at the Sundance Film Festival, is her third major act.
The first was “Tiny Furniture,” the 2010 movie that launched her, and it was a gem: the portrait of a wayward young New York striver, played by Dunham, told on an unusual level of lacerating honesty. When I saw it I thought: There’s something about how this filmmaker views her lead character — with open eyes, showing us her dreams but also, in close-up, all her flaws — that cuts against the grain not just of Hollywood but of so much indie-film piety.
Dunham’s second act was “Girls,” and that was a one-series revolution: not the first HBO show to feel “like a movie,” but the first to feel like it was beating the independent-film world at its own game. By shifting her allegiance, so early in her career, from big screen to small, Dunham anticipated the streaming paradigm we’re in now — and “Girls” was also, of course, just a fantastic series, disarmingly funny and microscopically observant about the knowing self-delusions of the millennial state of mind.
Even if you weren’t in the demo, the show was chock-full of characters who felt like projections of so many of us.All of which is to say that the bar for “Sharp Stick” is high, because that’s where Lena Dunham’s track record of artistry has put it. It’s the first movie she has written and directed since “Tiny Furniture” (as an actor, she gives herself a supporting role this time), and with all the clout she now has in the entertainment
.