All My Life doesn't have to try too hard to . Based on a , the romantic drama follows Solomon Chau () and Jennifer Carter (Jessica Rothe), an adorable couple whose perfect romance is rudely interrupted by a devastating cancer diagnosis. Sol and Jen meet at a sports bar where the would-be chef charms the psych student by dunking on his embarrassing friends (one played by Jay Pharoah) and viewers are immediately swept up by a romance for the elder millennial age.