Plans to close a car park in the Bathgate Hills which is popular with stargazers have been criticised by a local councillor. A consultation process is under way in Bathgate but local SNP member Willie Boyle described it as "Hobson's Choice" as it only offered a single option of closing the car park at night. And he said the public should have more of a say instead of being asked a loaded question. And he pointed out that the Hilltop car park was designed to serve an access path up to Cairnpapple which has now been fenced off.