‘A Band of Dreamers and a Judge’ Review: An Imbalanced Iranian Treasure-Hunting Doc About Its Own Making
30.04.2024 - 01:29
/ variety.com
Siddhant Adlakha A film that pivots around a court case about its own making, buried treasure documentary “A Band of Dreamers and a Judge” features hints of allure that eventually wane. Shot in Iran, where unauthorized excavations remain illegal, Hesam Eslami’s chronicle of a group of treasure hunters is an occasionally intense process piece that often loses steam, especially during its attempts at intimate portraiture.
The movie’s grave-robbing subjects lead full and complex lives, but it seldom depicts them with the richness they deserve. Eslami’s framing device is unique.
The story begins with his cross-examination by a female judge, who questions his motives in filming footage a year prior, of a band of middle-aged friends obsessed with finding lost antiquities in the mountains of Savadkooh. This year-old footage makes up most of the movie’s runtime, plenty of which is dedicated to the group’s personal lives.
Unfortunately, the more its lens remains trained on their behind-the-scenes dynamics, the less focused it feels, thanks to its numerous lengthy, static scenes of interpersonal drama that pale in comparison to its riveting depictions of Indiana Jones-esque adventuring (minus the grand theatrics). “A Band of Dreamers and a Judge” is front loaded with nerve-wracking guerilla filmmaking, with moments so gripping that the rest of the movie seldom measures up.
During illicit nighttime digs — backed by Younes Eskandari’s sharp, eerie, horror-adjacent score — cinematographer Hamed Hoseini Sangari trains the camera’s gaze not on the group themselves, but on the harsh and hilly landscape they traverse, lit by makeshift flashlights that illuminate only slivers of space at a time. Scenes of recon and eventual rock clearing
.
The website popstar.one is an aggregator of news from open sources. The source is indicated at the beginning and at the end of the announcement. You can
send a complaint on the news if you find it unreliable.