Katie Thurston. On Monday night's episode of , Katie sent the pro football player home in heartbreaking fashion.ET spoke with Andrew at the taping for the upcoming Men Tell All special, and he confessed that, though the breakup is «still a little raw,» he isn't completely ruling out the possibility of trying a relationship with Katie again if she turns out to be single.«The way we kind of left, it was just kind of a bunch of questions in the air.