Two months after Colton Underwood and Cassie Randolph’s breakup, the former Bachelor star seems to have his eyes on a Pretty Little Liar. E! News recently reported that Colton and actress Lucy Hale have been hanging out and going on "casual dates." "It's nothing serious but they are both interested in each other," a source told the international outlet. "Colton has spent time at Lucy's house these past couple of weeks and they have gone on a few casual dates.