Spoilers below for the season finale of 1883, so be warned if you haven’t yet watched!As if 1883’s trauma-filled season finale didn’t already have Yellowstone franchise fans thrown for an emotional and reference-filled loop, creator and timeline spearheader Taylor Sheridan followed the episode up by seemingly shooting a poisoned arrow through the belief that the Dutton ranch’s origin story will be returning for an official Season 2. Which is weird, obviously, since Paramount+ is where the news about 1883’s next chapter was first announced.